Current Market Dynamics
The energy insurance sector is experiencing unprecedented capacity levels, leading to a softening market driven by a complex interplay of profitability concerns and competitive market share strategies, as highlighted in a recent Willis report.
The Energy Market Review reveals that the downstream sector is witnessing incremental rate reductions, a consequence of a relatively loss-free 2024. Insurers seem to have swiftly moved past the years of poor performance that preceded this period of stability.
However, the first quarter of 2025 has already seen a surge in potential losses, totaling $1.5 billion, surpassing the entire loss count for 2024. Analysts suggest this could influence the ongoing softening trend.
Market Opportunities
In a shifting market, downstream energy companies have the opportunity to harness current conditions to manage volatility effectively. Those prioritizing rate optimization stand to gain from heightened insurer competition for high-quality business.
Upstream Market Observations
The upstream sector has experienced a 5% growth in capacity due to a year of low loss activity, perpetuating a soft market. According to Willis analysts, insurers are under pressure to expand their market share, resulting in competitive signings even for core business, often at significant reductions. More underwriters are willing to assume leadership roles, further driving down prices.
Despite a historically poor loss record, many insurers have already met their 2025 budget allocations due to the high volume of construction business they are writing, despite its prior underperformance.
Liability Market Conditions
While international liability markets have seen profitability in three out of the last ten years, with the last two years marking consecutive gains, the US casualty market remains a notable exception amid the overall softening trend.
Social inflation continues its upward trajectory, with settlements increasing in size and scope. As a result, carriers across all segments are scrutinizing limits and premiums more closely.
The North American energy casualty market exhibits mixed conditions. While primary liability maintains a stable outlook, the oilfield services segment faces challenges due to higher loss frequency and severity. No significant changes in market dynamics are anticipated for 2025.
Insights from Industry Leaders
Rupert Mackenzie, Global Head of Natural Resources at Willis, highlights the energy sector’s significant premium volumes, attracting capital providers and fostering competition. As underwriting teams refine their risk selection processes, a flight to quality is evident, with the most desirable risks securing favorable terms. Nevertheless, profitability remains a critical issue for insurers.
The Role of Energy Storage in Transition
The report underscores the critical role of energy storage in the clean energy transition. As electrification advances, reliable and efficient energy storage becomes essential, introducing new risks such as supply chain disruptions and safety concerns.
Marie Reiter, Global Head of Broking Strategy, Natural Resources, at Willis, remarked, “2025 marks a pivotal year for the energy transition. Companies that invest in robust risk management strategies and collaborate with insurers to develop tailored coverage solutions will build resilience, balancing short-term fossil fuel investments with long-term decarbonization plans.”
News
